|
Karl
Mogel is a young man who, while an undergraduate, started a science column
in the Cal Aggie, the student newspaper at the University of California at
Davis.
Karl's writing career started almost by accident. He wrote an opinion
piece criticizing an article on "nonexistent" global warming that had
appeared in the paper. After that he was invited to produce more articles
for the paper. He later started a regular science column that ran for
three years. Karl related to us many of his experiences in debunking
pseudo-science and in confronting those advancing anti-scientific agendas.
He took on the author of an astrology column in the Cal Aggie. He also
related his experiences attending meetings at which "intelligent design"
was espoused.
Karl said that the easy kind of irrationality to deal with is that in
which the adherents openly admit that there could be no facts that could
possibly cause them to change their opinion. The obviously closed mind is
easy to debunk. Somewhat more difficult are the proponents of "intelligent
design," but after a little digging they clearly appear as advocates of an
updated creationism. Karl mentioned that, in 1987, the creationist tome,
"Of Pandas and People," was rewritten to replace the word "creationism"
with "intelligent design" everywhere it occurred. He questions the ethics
of "intelligent design" proponents.
Karl opened himself to questions and we had a give and take discussion.
One of the issues raised was a lawsuit by a fundamentalist high school
challenging the right of the University of California to reject its
science and other classes that do not meet the University’s academic
standards.
Report prepared by Wayne Luney, Recorder
Click
below to return to the list of 2006 Meetings or to go to the previous or
next meeting report.
|